When Helping Isn't Helpful

Recently, I was spending time with my family, and we'd been having some really good conversations about some pretty tender topics.

At one point, I found myself alone with my niece. I could tell she was processing a lot of what we'd been talking about, and she was getting a little teary.

So I did what came naturally. I tried to help.

I shared some words of love and affirmation — something I'd actually been thinking about for a while and wanted her to know.

It was heartfelt. It was true. And I meant every word.

But afterward, I found myself wondering whether it was actually helpful.

You see, what I shared was something that had been particularly meaningful to me. And looking back, I realize I was probably more focused on sharing that meaningful message than on discovering what she actually needed.

I didn't really know what was behind her tears. I hadn't asked. And just because something was meaningful for me to share didn't necessarily mean it was what she needed to hear at that moment.

Maybe it was. Maybe it wasn't.

I still don't know.

And it's gotten me thinking about the ways we try to help the people we care about.

When Good Intentions Miss the Mark

Most of us want to be helpful. When a family member, a friend, a co-worker, or our whole work team is struggling, we’re ready to roll up our sleeves.

We see a problem, and we want to solve it. We see someone hurting, and we want to make it better. We see someone facing a challenge, and we want to share what we've learned.

None of those are bad things!

But sometimes, in our eagerness to help, we respond with what we have to offer rather than stopping to consider what the other person actually needs.

I know I do this.

Even as a professional coach, I sometimes have to resist the urge to jump in with ideas, insights, or suggestions.

After all, people are paying me to help them. I want to provide value!

But I've learned that my most valuable contribution often isn't an answer or a brilliant suggestion. It's listening carefully, asking a thoughtful question, or helping someone discover an answer for themselves.

And that can be harder than it sounds.

Because sometimes the way we're most comfortable helping isn't the way someone needs to be helped.

Sometimes Helping Means Stepping Back

I was reminded of this recently through some leadership development work.

Following a workshop I facilitated, a leader and his team had an honest conversation about how they were working together. They recognized that while his guidance and direction had been valuable, the team had grown in their competence and confidence.

They didn't need as much direction anymore.

In fact, what they needed most was a little more freedom to take ownership and make decisions themselves.

This is something I talk about when teaching leadership development. As people grow in their skills and confidence, the kind of leadership they need changes.

Early on, they may need clear direction, instruction, and encouragement. But as they become more capable, they often need us to step back and trust them.

And that can be surprisingly difficult for leaders.

We want our people to grow. We want them to become capable, confident, and independent.

But when they do, they need us less.

And for those of us who find meaning and satisfaction in being helpful, that can be a little uncomfortable.

Sometimes the very thing we've been working toward requires us to let go of the role we've grown comfortable playing.

It happens in leadership with teams that grow and develop.  It happens in parenting as kids mature and spread their wings.  It happens in teaching as students develop mastery and in ministry as volunteers become more empowered.  And it happens in coaching, as clients become increasingly confident in making their own decisions.  

When being helpful becomes part of how I see myself, it can be surprisingly difficult to recognize when my help isn't actually needed.

Who Am I Really Helping?

I think this is where the question gets a little more personal. And maybe even uncomfortable.

When I jump in to solve a problem, offer advice, or provide encouragement, whose needs am I responding to?

The other person's? Or perhaps, at least in part, my own?

Maybe I like being the one with the answer. Maybe I feel responsible for making things better. Maybe it's uncomfortable to watch someone struggle. Or maybe I have something meaningful to share, and I'm eager to share it.

I don't think any of those motivations make us selfish or uncaring.

Quite the opposite. Often they come from our genuine desire to love and serve others well.

But even good intentions deserve a little examination – because they might have an impact we didn’t intend.

We might stunt someone's growth — or that of an entire team. We might create dependence rather than develop confidence and ownership. We might inadvertently communicate that we don't trust others or believe in their capabilities.

For me, there's a spiritual dimension to this, too.

Servant leadership isn't simply about giving more of ourselves or doing more for others. It's about honoring those we lead by paying attention to what they truly need, rather than simply offering what comes most naturally to us. It's about being willing to set aside our own preferences — even our preferred ways of leading and helping — so that others can grow and flourish.

I see that in the example of Jesus. He didn't respond to everyone in exactly the same way. Sometimes he taught. Sometimes he healed. Sometimes he asked questions, offered a challenge, or simply accompanied someone along the way.  He met people where they were, responding to their needs rather than approaching everyone in the same way.

And I think that's at the heart of helping well.

Sometimes the most sacrificial thing we can do isn't to give more. It's to loosen our grip on how we think we should help.

What Does Helping Well Look Like?

Of course, none of this means we should stop offering advice, solving problems, or stepping in when someone needs assistance.

Sometimes people really do need our expertise. Sometimes they need us to dive in and lend a hand. Sometimes they need reassurance, encouragement, or someone to tell them they're loved.

And sometimes they need us to listen, ask a question, or give them room to figure something out for themselves.

The challenge is knowing the difference.

And I'm not sure there's a simple formula for that.

I suspect it begins with paying attention. To the person in front of us. To their circumstances, capabilities, and needs. And perhaps to our own motivations, too.

I've thought a few times about that conversation with my niece. I still don't know whether what I said was what she needed to hear.

But it's reminded me that having something good to offer isn't quite the same as knowing it's the right thing to offer.

So perhaps the next time I feel that familiar urge to jump in and help, I'll pause long enough to ask myself:

Is this what they need — or simply what I want to give?

Because sometimes helping well means doing something different from what comes naturally.

Sometimes I need to stretch beyond what's comfortable for me — because helping others flourish matters more than helping in the way that feels best to me.

Like this blog? 

Sign up to get new posts delivered directly to your inbox!